NVIDIA's GeForce 8800 (G80): GPUs Re-architected for DirectX 10

What's Gamma Correct AA?

Gamma correction is a technique used to map linearly increasing brightness data to a display device in a way that conveys linearly increasing intensity. As displays are nonlinear devices, gamma correction requires a nonlinear adjustment to be made to brightness values before being sent to the display. Ideally, gamma corrected linear steps in the brightness of a pixel will result in linear steps in perceived intensity. The application in antialiasing is that high contrast edges can appear under aliased if the brightness of a pixel isn't adjusted high enough for humans to perceive an increase in intensity after being displayed by the monitor.

Unfortunately, gamma correcting AA isn't always desirable. Different CRT, LCD, and TVs have different gamma characteristics that make choosing one gamma correction scheme more or less effective per device. It can also result in brighter colored sub-samples having a heavier influence on the color of a pixel than darker sub-samples. This causes problems for thing like thin lines.

To illustrate the difference, we'll look at images of Half-Life taken on G80 with and without gamma correction enabled.

16XQ No Gamma 16XQ Gamma

Hold mouse over links to see Image Quality

16XQ No Gamma 16XQ Gamma

Hold mouse over links to see Image Quality

We can see the antenna decrease in clarity due to the fact that each of the brighter subsamples has a disproportionately higher weight than the darker subsamples. As far as the roof line is concerned, our options are to see the roof blurring out into the sky, or watching the sky cut into the roof.

Really, edge AA with and without gamma correction is six of one and half a dozen of the other. Combine this with the fact that the effect is different depending on the monitor being used and the degraded visibility of thin lines and we feel that gamma correct AA isn't a feature that improves image quality as much as it just changes it.

While we are happy that NVIDIA has given us the choice to enable or disable gamma correct AA as we see fit, with G80 the default state has changed to enabled. While this doesn't have an impact on performance, we prefer rendering without gamma correct AA enabled and will do so in our performance tests. We hope that ATI will add a feature to disable gamma correct AA in the future as well. For now, let's take a look at R580 and G80 compared with gamma correction enabled.

G80 4X Gamma ATI 4X Gamma

Hold mouse over links to see Image Quality

G80 4X Gamma ATI 4X Gamma

Hold mouse over links to see Image Quality

At 4xAA with gamma correction enabled, it looks like ATI is able to produce a better quality image. Some of the wires and antenna on NVIDIA hardware area a little more ragged looking while ATI's images are smoothed better.