ATI HD 5870 Scaling Performance: X58 vs P55 Showdown
by Gary Key on September 29, 2009 12:00 PM EST- Posted in
- Motherboards
In just about every benchmark shown today and even in those not listed the multi-GPU results favor X58. Nothing shocking about that as in previous testing with both Nvidia and ATI video cards, we came to the same conclusion. The only difference today is that we are using the latest generation DX11 capable GPU and the percentage differences are not really any different with previous GPU chipsets. Where we did not have a difference was in actual game play experiences. It was impossible to tell the difference between platforms, except for some additional thermal output from the X58 setup.
If you happen to benchmark Intel platforms for a living, then clearly an X58/Bloomfield platform is the way to go. No questions asked, not even a hint of doubt should enter one’s mind as to the X58 being the logical choice. How about the other 99.9% of us? Well, if you just need that safe feeling that you are getting the maximum benefit out of those $380 HD 5870 cards you just purchased, the X58 paired with a Core i7 is an easy choice. It is an even easier choice if you plan on upgrading to Gulftown next year.
For those of us who are interested in power consumption, heat, noise, and not all that worried about a 2% to 7% difference in the benchmarks, then the Lynnfield platform is an attractive alternative with the latest generation GPUs. In fact, without the 920/X58 hanging around at similar pricing, the general thoughts/concerns regarding 860/P55 would probably be significantly different within the enthusiast community. The 860/P55 is a very good platform, especially for those running at stock or near stock speeds where the aggressive turbo mode will make a difference in daily computing tasks and your pocketbook.
That said, if you are running a single card such as the HD 5870, either platform is fine. However, performance in x8 mode was a bit disappointing for those needing the second slot for purposes other than graphics. In the end, performance in games was still very good and only a benchmark would inform you of less than stellar performance. What we cannot answer right now is if the dual x8 PCIe capability on Lynnfield will become a true bottleneck with the GPUs that follow the current/planned releases from AMD/Nvidia.
So our conclusion still has not changed from a month ago, if you plan on purchasing a high end multi-GPU setup you'll want to go with X58/Bloomfield for the best possible performance. If you want a great combination of application and gaming performance without the power consumption or heat concerns, the Lynnfield platform is a very attractive alternative.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
85 Comments
View All Comments
DigitalFreak - Tuesday, September 29, 2009 - link
I was being sarcastic, but whatever.There's not really a point in putting the 5850 through this test. It's not as powerful as the 5870, so the difference between the X58 and P55 would be even less.
jordanclock - Tuesday, September 29, 2009 - link
I think his point was that while it's great to see performance of an ultra-high end setup, we're more interested in seeing a review of the more affordable HD5850.goinginstyle - Tuesday, September 29, 2009 - link
I was being sarcastic. I know this had to take a lot of time and a lot of us asked for it. My statement did not go over the right way. I already sent an email to Gary stating as such and hoping they had banned the Toms guy by now but it appears they are letting him trash another article.szzcy - Sunday, June 10, 2012 - link
TOMS shoes are shoes with a noble cause associated with them. Buy one donate one. But the brand is far more than just a charity. Their unique designs and catchy colors make them a perfect choice for women who love to stand out of the crowd, the shoes from TOMS are more suitable for teenagers and youngsters because of their particular shape and looks. Let me explain you that why should you avail the offer of Toms shoes coupon code.The type of watch you wear says a lot about you as a person. Are you bold and courageous? Or do you love glitz and glamour? Express yourself by choosing a fashionable Tissot watch, in the world of fashion, where bling has become stylish, Tissot watches make an excellent choice for people who want to look their best.
From so many high-heel shoes kind, christian shoes trade is one of the best. They formed numerous shoes make a lady fanatical, they use their charisma to expand an independent shoe designer known, can be say that they are the most infamous contemporary masters of the shoes.
At here, you can locate out possibly probably the most luxury and most beneficial sellers inside the design field, along the lines of exquisite Gucci shoes, at ease and gentle Gucci clothing, cozy Gucci wool hats, etc. inside the exhibition in Gucci outlet online, you will locate available are three principal destinations available for you personally to choose.
The Converse shoes have been around since a long time and they are immediately recognized by their unique design and label, they were the first athletic shoes to be manufactured for the basketball players. Though they were originally designed for basketball players, soon its popularity grew and it became a regular shoe.
szzcy - Sunday, June 10, 2012 - link
TOMS shoes are shoes with a noble cause associated with them. Buy one donate one. But the brand is far more than just a charity. Their unique designs and catchy colors make them a perfect choice for women who love to stand out of the crowd, the shoes from TOMS are more suitable for teenagers and youngsters because of their particular shape and looks. Let me explain you that why should you avail the offer of Toms shoes coupon code.The type of watch you wear says a lot about you as a person. Are you bold and courageous? Or do you love glitz and glamour? Express yourself by choosing a fashionable Tissot watch, in the world of fashion, where bling has become stylish, Tissot watches make an excellent choice for people who want to look their best.
From so many high-heel shoes kind, christian shoes trade is one of the best. They formed numerous shoes make a lady fanatical, they use their charisma to expand an independent shoe designer known, can be say that they are the most infamous contemporary masters of the shoes.
At here, you can locate out possibly probably the most luxury and most beneficial sellers inside the design field, along the lines of exquisite Gucci shoes, at ease and gentle Gucci clothing, cozy Gucci wool hats, etc. inside the exhibition in Gucci outlet online, you will locate available are three principal destinations available for you personally to choose.
The Converse shoes have been around since a long time and they are immediately recognized by their unique design and label, they were the first athletic shoes to be manufactured for the basketball players. Though they were originally designed for basketball players, soon its popularity grew and it became a regular shoe.